An index of sociocultural development applicable to precivilized societies

American Anthropologist • Vol/Iss. 71 • Published In • Pages: 454-461 •
By Bowden, Edgar

Hypothesis

"Traits [loading above .5 on] rotated factor Index of Social Development [are]: permanency of residence, group life, agriculture, use of grain for food, constancy of food supply, domesticated animals other than herded, mining and smelting of metals, metals obtained from outside, pottery, weaving, money or other standard medium of exchange, trade, private property in land, power vested in a chief, codified laws, authority of judges, plutocracy, and organized priesthood" (456)

Test

Test NameSupportSignificanceCoefficientTail
Factor analysisSupportedUNKNOWNUNKNOWNUNKNOWN

Variables

Variable NameVariable Type OCM Term(s)
AgricultureUNKNOWNTillage
Authority Of JudgesUNKNOWNJudicial Authority
Codified LawsUNKNOWNLegal Norms
Constancy Of Food SupplyUNKNOWNDiet
Domesticated Animals Other Than HerdedUNKNOWNDomesticated Animals
Factor: Index Of Sociocultural DevelopmentUNKNOWNEconomic Planning And Development
Group LifeUNKNOWNSocial Relationships And Groups
Metals Obtained From OutsideUNKNOWNExternal Trade
Mining And Smelting Of MetalsUNKNOWNMetallurgy
Money Or Other Standard Medium Of ExchangeUNKNOWNMedium Of Exchange
Organized PriesthoodUNKNOWNPriesthood
Permanency Of ResidenceUNKNOWNSettlement Patterns
PlutocracyUNKNOWNForm And Rules Of Government
PotteryUNKNOWNCeramic Technology
Power Vested In ChiefUNKNOWNChief Executive
Private Property In LandUNKNOWNReal Property
TradeUNKNOWNInternal Trade
Use Of Grain For FoodUNKNOWNDiet
WeavingUNKNOWNWoven And Other Interworked Fabrics

Related Hypotheses

Main AuthorHypothesis
Gouldner, Alvin W.Findings: Factor T, "Level of Technology", with its stress on pottery and grain for food is suggestive of neolithic technology. The two heaviest positive loadings (oblimax rotation) were noted above. Other heavy positive loadings are: mining and smelting, prevalence of war, basketry, money, weaving, herding, agriculture, domesticated animals other than herded. Highest negative loadings are: warm climate, legendary heroes, fishing, and patrilocal residence (25)
Gouldner, Alvin W.Findings: Factor A, "Apollonianism or Norm-Sending", has high positive loadings (oblimax rotation) for: elaboration of ceremony and ritual, organized priesthood, authority vested in judges, power vested in chief, government by restricted council, and attractiveness of future life. Highest negative loadings are for marriage by capture and domesticated animals other than herded.
Rudmin, Floyd WebsterCertain characteristics of societies will be significantly correlated in the same direction with both Simmons' (137) and Murdock's (1967) measures of private property ownership.
Murdock, George Peter". . . patrilineal institutions [are] associated with the presence of traits indicative of higher civilization, matrilineal institutions with their absence. [Some of these are:] agriculture, [animal] domestication, writing, pottery, weaving, metals, [labor] specialization, money, [social] classes, government [and] priesthood . . ." (467)
Simmons, Leo W.". . . .in customs of food sharing with the aged there has been no significant difference in the treatment accorded to aged men and women (34)