A quantitative global test of the complexity trade-off hypothesis: the case of nominal and verbal grammatical marking

Linguistics Vanguard Vol/Iss. 9(s1) Walter de Gruyter GmbH Published In Pages: 155-167
By Shcherbakova, Olena, Gast, Volker, Blasi, Damian E., Skirgård, Hedvig, Gray, Russell D. , Greenhill, Simon J.

Abstract

The "equi-complexity hypothesis" suggests that there is an equal complexity across languages, meaning that there are constant trade-offs between different domains. Using phylogenetic modelling in a sample of 244 languages, this study follows a diachronic perspective to explore if there is an inversed coevolution within the grammatical coding of nominal and verbal domains. The results show that while there appears to be a coevolutionary relationship between some features of these two domains, there is no evidence to support the idea that all languages maintain an overall equilibrium of grammatical complexity. Rather, the correlation nominal and verbal domains vary between lineages. Austronesian languages do not show a coevolution between the domains. Sino-Tibetan languages seem to have a positive correlation while Indo-European languages appear to have a negative correlation, meaning that this inverse coevolution can be lineage specific.

Samples

Sample Used Coded Data Comment
GrambankOther researchers244 languages from this cross-linguistic database.

Documents and Hypotheses Filed By:stefania.becerralavado